Skip advert
Advertisement

Winter tyres test 2015/2016: Results by category

Test-by-test scores show you which tyre performed well where - plus our overall verdict

We've included the Vredestein all-season tyre and Goodyear summer tyre in our results tables to show how their performance compared with the best winter tyres. Again, we’re keen to stress the difference winter tyres make when the temperature falls below seven degrees Celsius. It can be hard to persuade drivers to splash out around £100 per corner if they haven’t experienced this, but our results tables demonstrate that it can be money well spent.

Snow braking 
1Nokian100%
2Uniroyal99.60%
3Goodyear99.50%
4Continental98.10%
5Michelin98%
6Dunlop97.00%
7Pirelli95.80%
8Hankook94.50%
 -Vredestein a/s88.50%
 -Goodyear summer39.30%
   
Snow traction 
1Nokian100%
2Uniroyal99.20%
3Continental97.80%
4Michelin97.90%
5Goodyear97.10%
6Pirelli94.10%
7Dunlop93.70%
8Hankook92.60%
 -Vredestein a/s93.60%
 -Goodyear summer29.60%
   
Snow circle  
 1.=Nokian100%
 1.= Michelin100%
3Uniroyal99.90%
 4.=Goodyear99.40%
 4.=Pirelli98.40%
6Continental98.30%
7Dunlop97.60%
8Hankook96.90%
 -Vredestein a/s94.60%
 -Goodyear summer0.00%
   
Snow handling 
1Nokian100%
2Goodyear99.70%
3Michelin98.40%
4Uniroyal98.30%
5Dunlop98.10%
6Continental97.50%
7Pirelli97.40%
8Hankook96.10%
 -Vredestein a/s95.00%
 -Goodyear summer0.00%
   
Straight aqua 
1Nokian100%
2Uniroyal99.30%
3Continental97.80%
4Hankook97.70%
5Goodyear96.70%
6Michelin94.50%
7Dunlop94.20%
8Pirelli91.00%
 -Vredestein a/s86.30%
 -Goodyear summer96.10%
   
Curved aqua 
1Hankook100%
2Nokian94.40%
3Goodyear90.80%
4Continental90.70%
5Uniroyal90.40%
6Michelin86.50%
7Dunlop85.90%
8Pirelli68.70%
 -Vredestein a/s89.40%
 -Goodyear summer78.80%
   
Wet braking  
1Continental100%
2Pirelli98.10%
3Michelin96.20%
4Goodyear95.70%
5Uniroyal95.40%
6Dunlop93.60%
7Nokian92.50%
8Hankook90.40%
 -Vredestein a/s93.20%
 -Goodyear summer86.20%
   
Wet Handling 
1Pirelli100%
2Continental99.60%
3Goodyear99.20%
4Michelin98.70%
5Uniroyal98.40%
6Dunlop98.00%
7Nokian97.00%
8Hankook94.20%
 -Vredestein a/s96.60%
 -Goodyear summer96.30%
   
Dry braking  
1Nokian100%
2Dunlop99.20%
3Continental97.90%
4Pirelli97.50%
5Hankook97.10%
6Michelin96.70%
 7.=Goodyear93.70%
 7.=Uniroyal93.70%
 -Vredestein a/s98.40%
 -Goodyear summer109.50%
   
Dry handling 
1Nokian100%
2Hankook99.90%
 3.=Michelin99.60%
 3.=Pirelli99.60%
5Goodyear98.90%
6Continental98.80%
7Dunlop98.70%
8Uniroyal98.60%
 -Vredestein a/s100.80%
 -Goodyear summer102.10%
   
Cabin noise  
1Pirelli100%
2Dunlop99.80%
 3.=Continental99.20%
 3.=Goodyear99.20%
 3.=Uniroyal99.20%
6Michelin99.10%
7Nokian98.80%
8Hankook98.00%
 -Vredestein a/s98.60%
 -Goodyear summer99.00%
   
Rolling resistance 
1Continental100%
2Goodyear98.80%
3Dunlop94.00%
4Michelin87.10%
5Pirelli85.90%
6Uniroyal85.60%
7Hankook83.90%
8Nokian83.30%
 -Vredestein a/s93.00%
 -Goodyear summer109.40%
   
Price  
1Hankook£82.49
 2.=Dunlop£91.99
 2.=Goodyear£91.99
4Michelin£99.49
5Nokian£100.99
6Uniroyal£101.99
7Pirelli£106.99
8Continental£120.99
 -Vredestein a/s£109.49
 -Goodyear summer£67.99
   
Overall  
1Continental100%
2Nokian99.50%
3Goodyear99.40%
4Uniroyal98.60%
5Michelin98.40%
6Dunlop98.00%
7Pirelli96.90%
8Hankook96.70%
 -Vredestein a/s95.80%
 -Goodyear summerNR

Overall verdict

Hankook and Pirelli sit at the foot of the table, but are by no means disgraced and are safe, if thirsty, winter tyres. In the middle of the pack are the Michelin, Dunlop and new Uniroyal tyres, which deliver very similar performances. No pairing is more closely matched than former winners Goodyear and Nokian. But another past champ takes overall glory, in the shape of Continental’s superb all-rounder.

Skip advert
Advertisement

New & used car deals

Volkswagen Tiguan

Volkswagen Tiguan

RRP £35,080Avg. savings £3,743 off RRP*
Skoda Kodiaq

Skoda Kodiaq

RRP £37,870Avg. savings £2,955 off RRP*
Renault Clio

Renault Clio

RRP £16,040Avg. savings £2,827 off RRP*Used from £8,958
Audi A3

Audi A3

RRP £26,075Avg. savings £2,213 off RRP*Used from £14,990
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Toyota Land Cruiser review
Toyota Land Cruiser - main image

Toyota Land Cruiser review

The latest Toyota Land Cruiser is more sophisticated, stylish, and tech-laden, but gives up none of its predecessor’s capability
In-depth reviews
20 Jan 2025
EV discounts: are they a short-term solution with long-term problems?
Vauxhall Corsa Electric front corner driving

EV discounts: are they a short-term solution with long-term problems?

Optimistic residual value projections for EVs have left vehicle leasing firms “millions and millions” out of pocket
News
18 Jan 2025
Car brands with the most recalls: BMW tops the UK recall chart in 2024
BMW 530e - front cornering

Car brands with the most recalls: BMW tops the UK recall chart in 2024

Did you receive a letter alerting you to a potentially dangerous car fault? Here are the car brands that sent the most out
News
17 Jan 2025