Skip advert
Advertisement

"American cars aren't as desirable as they used to be"

Cars from General Motors, Ford and Chrysler look "too American" to appeal worldwide, says Mike Rutherford

Had a good and productive day at ‘the office’ last week – driving and judging some of the World Car Awards nominees for 2016 in and around Los Angeles.

A handful of the contenders at this Californian Test Fest were from outside the USA. But most were from within. And cars from GM – still America’s number one – dominated. How come? Becausethe cold, harsh truth is that in 2015/16, The General is putting on sale across the world far more new models than comparatively sleepy US rivals, Ford and Chrysler.

Advertisement - Article continues below

For being so active, GM deserves much praise. But while America’s biggest vehicle manufacturing operation obviously doesn’t have issues designing and churning out new product, it is creating problems for itself by making its cars too, er, American. 

"America can keep its guns, but there are plenty of motoring ideas it should send our way"

I can explain. Sitting alongside GM’s ‘brawn in the USA’ beasts at the LA Test Fest were, for example, the Volvo XC90 plus all-new versions of the Mazda MX-5 and Toyota Prius. This trio showed no visual evidence of their Swedish or Japanese origins. Instead, they genuinely looked like cars for the world – or, in the case of the deliciously bonkers Prius, a car for (and from) another planet.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Conversely, the GM/Cadillac/Chevrolet rivals they’re competing with for World Car honours not only looked unmistakably American, but felt, smelt and shouted American, too. This might work for consumers in the US. But on a global scale, they don’t have the same resonance.

New Cadillac XT5 SUV revealed at LA 2015 show

In the past, when the world was a smaller place, major selling points for Caddys and Chevys were that they were big/bold, loud/proud hunks of Detroit iron. They looked, felt, drove, sounded and screamed USA, land of the free, living the American dream and all that. But that was then. And this is now. Tastes have changed. Less is very often more. Increasingly sophisticated and well travelled consumers from all corners of the globe – The Americas included – are rapidly concluding that American cars aren’t as desirable as they used to be. 

• Cadillac CTS-V review

And they’re not priced as well as they used to be, either. Together, the brilliant XC90 plus the scintillatingly good MX-5 at the World Car Test Fest could be bought for less money than one merely adequate Cadillac CTS-V. Such price-related madness is almost as bonkers as the insane exterior appearance of the latest Toyota Prius.

Do you agree with Mike? Let us know below...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

New Cadillac Lyriq UK pricing leaked online, and it’ll be more expensive than a BMW iX
Cadillac Lyriq - front tracking

New Cadillac Lyriq UK pricing leaked online, and it’ll be more expensive than a BMW iX

Prices for the luxury electric SUV will apparently start from £75,000, and it’ll offer 329 miles of range
News
11 Dec 2024
Monterey Car Week 2024: full show round-up and all the exclusive, luxury and performance cars
Pebble Beach Tour d'Elegance

Monterey Car Week 2024: full show round-up and all the exclusive, luxury and performance cars

Some of the most iconic car brands lined up to unveil new metal in Monterey
News
20 Aug 2024
Cadillac Sollei Concept harks back to glamorous ‘50s land yacht cabriolets
Cadillac Sollei concept - front static

Cadillac Sollei Concept harks back to glamorous ‘50s land yacht cabriolets

Large and luxurious four-seat convertibles were once at the heart of Cadillac’s eccentric image, something this new concept might just recreate
News
22 Jul 2024
New Cadillac Optiq EV to spearhead UK relaunch by end of 2024
Cadillac Optiq - front

New Cadillac Optiq EV to spearhead UK relaunch by end of 2024

America’s premium brand is coming back to the UK with an all-electric headline
News
29 May 2024

Most Popular

New Toyota MR2 is all but confirmed
Toyota MR2 design render (watermarked)

New Toyota MR2 is all but confirmed

Work is under way on a new petrol two-seater that will use the mid-engined powertrain from Toyota's Tokyo Auto Salon concept
News
22 Jan 2025
Toyota Land Cruiser review
Toyota Land Cruiser - main image

Toyota Land Cruiser review

The latest Toyota Land Cruiser is more sophisticated, stylish, and tech-laden, but gives up none of its predecessor’s capability
In-depth reviews
20 Jan 2025
EV discounts: are they a short-term solution with long-term problems?
Vauxhall Corsa Electric front corner driving

EV discounts: are they a short-term solution with long-term problems?

Optimistic residual value projections for EVs have left vehicle leasing firms “millions and millions” out of pocket
News
18 Jan 2025