Skip advert
Advertisement

Dacia Duster vs MG ZS: which is the best budget hybrid SUV?

The new Dacia Duster and MG ZS are the UK’s cheapest small SUVs. Which makes more sense in hybrid form?

“All the car you ever need” is something of a cliché, but at the same time it’s a phrase that raises a very pertinent question, given the current landscape of the UK market. Vast SUVs with six-figure price tags, and plug-in hybrids that struggle to deliver better efficiency than regular hybrids make you wonder if there’s a simpler way.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Well here’s a pair of new SUVs with hybrid assistance. Neither takes up much space on the road, nor will they make a big dent in your bank account. The first is from Dacia, a brand that has long stood for value for money, and while the latest Duster aims a little higher in terms of its social standing by displaying a more rugged, adventurous side, it’s still something of a bargain, with even the top-spec model weighing in at under £27,000. 

Up against it is a brand with a familiar name that has waded into the same bargain-priced space that Dacia has occupied almost exclusively for years. The first MG ZS was a cheap family car that ticked many boxes, but its internal-combustion powertrain options were limited. Now MG hopes that a fresh model with a new hybrid powertrain will lift it fully into Dacia’s territory.

Dacia Duster

Model:Dacia Duster Hybrid Journey
Price:£25,945
Powertrain:4cyl, 1,598cc petrol engine, plus 2x e-motors, multi-mode auto, 138bhp
0-62mph:10.1 seconds
Test efficiency:52.3mpg
Official range:575 miles
Annual VED:£180

Dacia wants to pitch itself as an outdoorsy, lifestyle brand, and the Dacia Duster is the car in its line-up that fits that bill best of all.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

The third generation of the small SUV has a more chunky look than its predecessor; it hasn’t just gained some brawn, but also some brains courtesy of a new hybrid powertrain and much-improved in-car tech, too. The Hybrid model kicks off from £24,245, but a base petrol/LPG version, badged Bi-Fuel, with a manual gearbox, is cheaper still, at £18,745.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Tester’s notes

The third-generation Duster has adopted a tough new look, with more thought being put into not only its overall shape, but many of the finer details, too. The squared-off bonnet edges give a distinctive appearance from behind the wheel, but also help the driver to place the front of the car in tight spots. Chunky plastic cladding surrounds the lower portions
of the car, too. The ZS looks sharper than before but, huge front grille aside, it doesn’t stand out from the crowd like the Duster.

MG ZS

Model:MG ZS Hybrid+ Trophy
Price:£24,495
Powertrain:4cyl, 1,498cc petrol engine, plus 1x e-motor, three-speed auto, 193bhp
0-62mph:8.7 seconds
Test efficiency:48.7mpg
Official range:439 miles
Annual VED:£180

Over the past few years, the MG ZS has represented a very affordable way into EV ownership, but this new model is offered exclusively with the same petrol-electric powertrain that we’ve already sampled in our 2024 Affordable Hybrid Car of the Year, the MG3.

As it stands, sales of the all-electric version of the ZS continue alongside the newcomer, but a refreshed design inside and out – not to mention more modern in-car tech – makes this new ZS feel like a big step forward in several ways. 

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Tester’s notes 

Buyers have two trim levels to choose from: SE and Trophy. The former is the entry point into the range, and equipment levels are strong, with LED headlights, 17-inch alloy wheels, a 12.3-inch infotainment screen with a reversing camera and keyless entry – plus much more – as standard. The Trophy costs £2,500 extra and adds heated seats and steering wheel, a 360-degree parking camera, faux-leather upholstery, rear privacy glass plus 18-inch alloy wheels. Given the bargain pricing of both cars, we feel it’s worth stretching to the top-spec Trophy.

Head-to-head

On the road

Advertisement - Article continues below

In terms of performance, the MG takes a clear win in this contest, with excellent response around town in particular. The Dacia is more leisurely, a feeling reinforced by a fairly soft suspension set-up that promotes more relaxed driving. The Duster’s ride is also better and it feels secure on the road. Both cars have issues with refinement; for the Dacia it’s wind noise, while the MG’s vice is tyre roar at higher speeds.

Tech highlights
Hybrid power is the only option available to buyers of the new ZS from launch. It’s impressive on paper, though, both in terms of its 1.83kWh battery and the 134bhp produced by its e-motor. That latter number is almost as much as the 138bhp produced by the combined total of the Dacia’s electric and petrol sources. The Duster’s unusual clutchless gearbox takes inspiration from F1.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Price and running
Both cars return roughly 55mph on the WLTP cycle, but in the real world it’s the Dacia that proved more able to approach that figure, hitting 52.3mpg to the MG’s 48.7mpg. Both cars cost a similar amount with hybrid powertrains on board, but the MG has more standard kit and stronger performance. However, Duster buyers can save another £3,000 and choose the mild-hybrid petrol instead. 

Practicality
There’s not much to separate this pair when it comes to interior or storage space – both are impressive. The Duster offers rear seat passengers a little more headroom, but the ZS has more generous kneeroom. Both have a similar boot volume, but non-hybrid Dusters offer more underfloor storage space and better cubby spaces in the cabin. The MG, however, has a lower boot lip for easier loading.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Safety
The likes of lane-change warning and a driver-fatigue warning system are fitted to the Duster as standard, with blind-spot warning available on Journey and Extreme trims, but even so, a three-star Euro NCAP rating is a bit disappointing Adaptive cruise control is standard on both MG ZS trim levels, as is blind-spot warning, lane-departure assist, and an active emergency braking system.

Ownership
Both cars are built to a price, but Dacia’s bean counters have chosen their battles better. MG has tried to give a veneer of poshness that has meant scrimping on some basics; there’s no reach-adjustment for the steering wheel and the fake leather feels slippery. The Dacia is more upfront about its penny pinching when it comes to hard plastics inside, but its ergonomics feel better considered.

Verdict

First place: Dacia Duster

Dacia might claim to be shuffling gradually away from its purely budget origins, but the Duster is still a bargain family SUV. However, it has more character than ever before; it looks unique, feels robust on the road, yet offers comfort that sets it apart from most rivals.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

While the MG has it beaten for performance, everywhere else it’s much tighter; the Duster’s more honest, no-nonsense nature and desirability – not to mention its larger range of engines and trims with a lower starting price – are what seals its win here.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Second place: MG ZS

Against most other competition in this segment, the ZS would have had the talent to breeze to an easy victory – it’s only the Dacia’s all-round ability that confines the MG to second.

The MG is by no means a perfect car (we have questions over its fit and finish, the driving position, and the driveability of an otherwise very rapid powertrain), but those flaws are easier to forgive when you start to appreciate just what a strongly priced, well equipped and practical family SUV it is. It’s another big step in the right direction for MG.

Prices and specs

 Dacia DusterMG ZS
Our choiceHybrid JourneyHybrid+ Trophy
Price from/price of our choice£18,745/£25,945£21,995/£24,495
POWERTRAIN AND PERFORMANCE  
Powertrain4cyl, 1,598cc, 2x e-motors4cyl, 1,498cc, 1 e-motor
Power138bhp193bhp
Torque205Nm343Nm
TransmissionMulti-mode auto/fwdThree-speed auto/fwd
0-62mph/top speed10.1 secs/105mph8.7 secs/115mph
Fuel tank50 litres/1.2kWh41 litres/1.83kWh
Test MPG52.3mpg48.7mpg
Test range575 miles439 miles
Charging114g/km115g/km
DIMENSIONS  
Length/wheelbase4,343/2,657mm4,430/2,610mm
Width/height1,921/1,616mm1,818/1,635mm
Rear kneeroom605-735mm645-882mm
Rear headroom/ elbow room974/1,432mm954/1,435mm
Boot space (frunk/ seats up/down)430/1,545 litres443/1,457 litres
Boot length/width870/1,005mm874/1,005mm
Boot lip height805mm704mm
Kerbweight/ towing weight1,455/750kg1,420/500kg
Turning circle10.9 metres10.5 metres
COSTS/OWNERSHIP  
Residuals (3yrs/36k miles)£14,794/57.0%£12,424/50.7%
Depreciation£11,151£9,571
Insurance group/quote/VED24/£503/£18022/£571/£180
Three-year service cost£468£729 (est)
Annual tax liability std/higher rate£1,295/£2,590£1,357/£2,714
Annual fuel cost (10k miles)£1,220£1,310
Basic warranty (miles)/recovery3yrs (60,000)/3yrs7yrs (80,000)/1yr
Driver Power manufacturer position22nd/3232nd/32
Euro NCAP Adult/child/ped./assist/stars70/84/60/57/3 (2024)N/A
EQUIPMENT  
Metallic paint/wheel size£650/17 inches£545/18 inches
Parking sensors/reversing cameraF&r/yesF&r/360
Spare wheel/Isofix points£300/twoRepair kit/two
Keyless entry & go/powered tailgateYes/noYes/yes
Leather trim/heated seatsNo/noFaux/yes
Screen size/digital dashboard10.1 inches/yes12.3 inches/yes
Climate control/panoramic sunroofYes/noYes/yes
USB count/wireless chargingFour/yesThree/yes
Wireless CarPlay/Android AutoYes/yesYes/yes
Blind-spot warning/head-up displayYes/noYes/no
Adaptive cruise control/steering assistNo/yesYes/yes

What we would choose 

Dacia Duster

There’s a wide range of accessories. Beyond those clever Youclip add-ons, there’s also a set of roof bars, plus you can purchase a tent that attaches to the open tailgate, transforming the cabin into a roomy campsite.

MG ZS

The scope for customisation is very narrow for ZS buyers, with choices limited to the two trim levels and the six exterior paint colour options. Battersea Blue and Dynamic Red are the most eye-catching choices.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief reviewer

Alex joined Auto Express as staff writer in early 2018, helping out with news, drives, features, and the occasional sports report. His current role of Chief reviewer sees him head up our road test team, which gives readers the full lowdown on our comparison tests.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Hot Land Rover Defender Octa in high demand with close to 3,000 orders at £150,000 each
Land Rover Defender Octa - front action

Hot Land Rover Defender Octa in high demand with close to 3,000 orders at £150,000 each

Buyers aren’t being deterred by the hefty asking price for the most powerful Defender yet, with 2,900 already signing up worldwide
News
12 Nov 2024
Car Deal of the Day: no-nonsense MG ZS EV for £226 per month
MG ZS EV - front tracking

Car Deal of the Day: no-nonsense MG ZS EV for £226 per month

Our Deal of the Day for 10 November comes from Carwow’s new leasing arm, Carwow Leasey
News
10 Nov 2024
Car Deal of the Day: 641bhp Hyundai Ioniq 5 N is a bargain at this price
Hyundai Ioniq 5 N - front action

Car Deal of the Day: 641bhp Hyundai Ioniq 5 N is a bargain at this price

The 2024 Auto Express Performance Car of the Year is now our Deal of the Day for 7 November
News
7 Nov 2024