Skip advert
Advertisement

Exclusive: UK refrigerated truck emissions equal to 1.8 million cars

Our investigation uncovers the £100 million Government subsidy for heavily polluting diesel refrigeration generators fitted to HGVs

HGV refrigerated truck

Tens of thousands of heavily polluting diesel-powered refrigeration generators are running on the UK’s roads every day, producing harmful emissions equivalent to roughly 1.8 million cars. They’re totally unregulated, and the diesel they run on is subsidised by Government to the tune of £100 million a year.

Transport Refrigeration Units (TRUs) are coolers that chill and freeze food in vans and lorries, making deliveries to supermarkets and convenience stores.  

Advertisement - Article continues below

London ULEZ to cover most of the city from 2021

Around 34,000 of these TRUs are powered by generators running on ‘red’ diesel, so their fuel attracts duty of just 11.14 pence per litre, not the 57.9ppl of regular diesel. The unregulated status of TRUs also means the amount of nitrogen oxide (NOx), non-methane hydrocarbons (NMHC) and particulate matter (PM) they pump out is far higher not only than a diesel car, but also than a non-refrigerated HGV.  

The UK will adopt EU legislation on TRUs in January, but the rules won’t apply to units already on our streets. They also allow new TRUs to emit as much as 14 times more NOx than a diesel HGV, and up to 40 times more PM. The Department for Transport says it is “determined” to improve air quality, and that forthcoming TRU rules “will mean new units are cleaner than before”. 

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

The Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) and the Treasury have launched a call for evidence into the use of red diesel, but no plans have yet emerged to stop TRUs using the fuel. 

We asked Defra why TRUs run on red diesel, and were told it “plans to make low-emission vans more affordable” and is asking businesses how they can “break down the barriers to the use of lower emissions machinery”. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

Best electric cars to buy now

The use of red diesel in TRUs is being defended by the £113billion UK food industry, with the Food Storage and Distribution Federation (FSDF) recently warning Environment Secretary Michael Gove that stopping the subsidy would add £100million to the cost of delivering food. Shane Brennan, FSDF chief executive, told us if the red diesel subsidy were removed, the result would be higher food prices for consumers. 

Brennan added that while “innovation is vital” in cutting emissions, “for many operators there remains no market-ready alternative equipment for refrigeration”. 

The £100million saving the FSDF says TRU operators get as a result of the red diesel subsidy means TRUs are using around 214 million litres of the fuel a year, emitting roughly 2.7 million kilograms of NOx and 8,600kg of PM as they do so – equivalent to around 1.8 million Euro 6 diesel cars. Lorries with TRUs are “dragging ‘puffing-billies’ round our streets”, according to Toby Peters, professor in cold economy at the University of Birmingham. He added that the red diesel dispensation means “we not only tolerate their disproportionate emissions, but also subsidise them”. 

Peters said the new rules “will not lift [TRU] emissions standards anywhere near other modern diesel engines” and that “practical and deliverable” alternatives, like liquid nitrogen cooling, are moving from extended trials into first sales.  

But he added: “Industries change when governments give the right signals. That’s what happened to the car industry. When you subsidise diesel, what hope do you have for alternative technologies?”

What do you think about the subsidised emissions from refrigerated HGVs? Let us know in the comments…

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

What is V2X? Vehicle to everything tech explained
Polestar 2 Long Range Single Motor connected to wallbox charger

What is V2X? Vehicle to everything tech explained

Connectivity is a huge thing in modern cars but Vehicle to Everything technology is going to make it even bigger…
Tips & advice
28 Oct 2024
ULEZ enforcement stepped up in light of £450 million debt
London Roads

ULEZ enforcement stepped up in light of £450 million debt

With Transport for London owed £376 million in unpaid penalty notices and facing large debts itself, it’s escalating efforts to punish drivers dodging…
News
17 Oct 2024
Renault's Refactory: inside the groundbreaking repair, restoration and recycling hub
Auto Express consumer reporter Tom Jervis standing outside the Renault ReFactory facility

Renault's Refactory: inside the groundbreaking repair, restoration and recycling hub

We go behind the scenes at Renault’s Refactory car recycling centre
Features
15 Oct 2024
MINI to offer fully recyclable interiors “within a generation”
MINI Aceman - cabin

MINI to offer fully recyclable interiors “within a generation”

Recyclability will form an integral part of MINI design as it looks to make its cars more sustainable
News
1 Oct 2024

Most Popular

Ford Capri review
Ford Capri - front

Ford Capri review

This is no sports car, nor even a retro reboot – rather a capable, refined and well-built EV that happens to sport a controversial name
In-depth reviews
29 Oct 2024
Car Deal of the Day: Renault Scenic is a 379-mile EV for £263 a month
Renault Scenic UK - front

Car Deal of the Day: Renault Scenic is a 379-mile EV for £263 a month

The Renault Scenic E-Tech is a great family electric car with plenty of kit - making it our Deal of the Day for Monday 28 October
News
28 Oct 2024
New Dacia Duster 2024 Hybrid review: electrical assistance suits superb small SUV
Dacia Duster Hybrid - front

New Dacia Duster 2024 Hybrid review: electrical assistance suits superb small SUV

The first ever Dacia Duster Hybrid is a hit from behind the wheel, but better options exist in the small SUV’s range
Road tests
30 Oct 2024