Skip advert
Advertisement

Electric and hybrid cars are killing the manual gearbox - and we won't miss it

Auto Express’ senior test editor argues that no one should be worried by the rising popularity of automatic ’boxes

Opinion - gearboxes

New statistics released by valuation expert cap hpi reveal that the automatic gearbox is making inroads on the dominance of the manual transmission in new cars sold in the UK. Last year, autos in all of their guises made up nearly 30 per cent of new-car sales, and in a decade automatics have seen a 118 per cent jump in numbers compared with manuals.

Advertisement - Article continues below

One reason behind this is obvious, with the increase in market share for direct-drive electric cars having an impact. Elsewhere, other than the Honda CR-Z, every hybrid and plug-in hybrid that’s been sold in the UK since the Toyota Prius first arrived at the start of the 21st Century has been an auto.

In the performance car market, virtually no hot hatches, sports or supercars come with manuals, reflecting the effect of motorsport, where sequential gearboxes packed with cutting-edge electronics are optimised to deliver seamless shifts.

Economies of scale are having an impact in the realm of everyday combustion engines, too. Car manufacturers faced with narrowing margins and constantly tightening emissions regulations have done the sums and seen that the cost of developing two transmissions doesn’t add up. And while autos are likely to be marginally more expensive to develop than manuals, more buyers are going to be able to purchase the former, so that’s the route that’s been taken. Look at the new-car prices in the back of the Auto Express magazine, and you’ll see a scarcity of manuals for sale, with less than a third of new models equipped with one.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

But is the rise of the automatic such a bad thing? From what I see on the road, maybe not. Driving in the UK can be such a pain, from the terrible roads to the people that use them, and there are so many issues to deal with. So if you’re not having to worry about what gear you’re in, then you’re giving more time to what’s happening around you. I know people who have passed their test in a manual, but only ever drive autos for the convenience. Who needs to deal with a third pedal in stop-start traffic, for example?

Of course the enthusiast class will decry the death of the manual and its ‘connection’ to driving. But just like autos, there are good ones and bad ones, and the best will still be available on the used market and in demand for those that want them. For Joe Public, who sees a car as transport to get from A to B, the move to autos is just another step in the evolution from the horseless carriage.

There are plenty of other rituals that we no longer participate in: adjusting the choke, for example, hand signals, even looking behind when reversing, because parking sensors and cameras help us out. Using a clutch to change gears will eventually be another piece of ‘old tech’, reminisced about by those that think things were better ‘back in the day’.

Tell us which new car you’re interested in and get the very best offers from our network of over 5,500 UK dealers to compare. Let’s go…

Skip advert
Advertisement
Senior test editor

Dean has been part of the Auto Express team for more than 20 years, and has worked across nearly all departments, starting on magazine production, then moving to road tests and reviews. He's our resident van expert, but covers everything from scooters and motorbikes to supercars and consumer products.

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

New Dacia Sandero spotted for the first time: fresh look for Europe’s best-selling car
Dacia Sandero facelift spied testing - front tracking

New Dacia Sandero spotted for the first time: fresh look for Europe’s best-selling car

The humble supermini’s makeover is inspired by the Dacia Spring EV, plus Duster and Bigster SUV
News
11 Mar 2025
Car Deal of the Day: Prices tumble for Ford's Explorer – bag one for £233 a month
Ford Explorer - front cornering

Car Deal of the Day: Prices tumble for Ford's Explorer – bag one for £233 a month

The Ford Explorer is one of the more fun-to-drive family electric SUVs around – and our Deal of the Day for 12 March.
News
12 Mar 2025
New all-electric Toyota C-HR+ revealed to challenge the Renault Scenic
Toyota C-HR+ - front

New all-electric Toyota C-HR+ revealed to challenge the Renault Scenic

The Toyota C-HR+ joins the Japanese brand's all-electric line-up, slotting between the Urban Cruiser and bZ4X
News
11 Mar 2025