Skip advert
Advertisement

Smart ForFour

Listen carefully... our Smart has an undiagnosed illness. The ForFour is been getting noisier by the day.

Pros
  • Styling, paint, fuel economy, Mercedes switchgear, <br/>many recyclable parts<br/>
Cons
  • Untraceable noise, no parcel shelf, semi-auto in town, doors need a hefty slam
Find your Smart ForFour
Compare deals from trusted partners on this car and previous models.
Or are you looking to sell your car?
Value my car
Fast, no-nonsense car selling
Value my car

Listen carefully... our Smart has an undiagnosed illness. During its six months with us the ForFour has provided nearly 8,000 miles of reliable motoring, but it's been getting noisier by the day.
The problem happens at speeds over 30mph, when a low-pitched humming can be heard above the engine note. It sounds to us like a wheel bearing or exhaust manifold glitch, but Smart's own technicians couldn't find any fault. We left the ForFour at the company's Brentford after-sales centre in west London for a day, but despite thorough investigation, the car had the mechanics flummoxed. Following our insistence that there was an unwelcome noise, three engineers took a test drive, but reported no problems.
As I remain convinced that I'm not imagining things, the only solution is for us to return to the London base with the car and drive out with a technician to flag up the sound as and when it occurs. Although staff have been as helpful and as accommodating as I could wish, this means taking time off work and is an inconvenience that I hoped would have been avoidable.
Another problem the Smart developed was irritatingly squeaky brakes. As luck would have it, the fault had resolved itself by the time we came to taking the car to Brentford. However, technicians were happy to check out the discs and pads anyway, and gave them a clean bill of health.
So has life with the ForFour been nothing but a headache? Thankfully, none of the Smart's ailments has had any effect on performance or economy. In fact, counting the cost at the pumps has become a thoroughly satisfying task. The consumption figure from the last report (issue 831) has been bettered by 14 per cent, with the ForFour now returning a penny-pinching 42.2mpg.
Unfortunately, the 95bhp engine has to be pushed hard to deliver swift acceleration, and I still can't get on with the semi-automatic gearbox. In making its trademark transmission more user-friendly by incorporating an auto-style creep from stationary and smoother changes, Smart has compromised driver involvement. Around town, however, where sporty handling is hardly a priority, passers-by have more time to admire the ForFour's eye-catching design.
I love the distinctive deep-green colour, and the bodywork is packed with interesting shapes and surfaces that set the ForFour apart from the norm. However, for now at least, the Smart's mystery illness has taken the shine off life with the car - check out future long-term updates to see if we can get to the bottom of the problem. Chris Thorp
Second Opinion
I understand what Chris means about the gearbox, but it's much smoother than the transmission used on the ForTwo. There are fewer jerky upshifts and, although it's much less involving, the sequential box seems to suit the brand's quirky character better than an ordinary manual. The glass roof makes the cabin light and airy, while the whole car has a style that the platform-sharing Mitsubishi Colt lacks. I just hope the mystery noise doesn't mean bad news. Dean Gibson, sub-editor

Skip advert
Advertisement

New & used car deals

Skoda Kodiaq

Skoda Kodiaq

RRP £38,140Avg. savings £3,019 off RRP*Used from £14,495
Nissan Qashqai

Nissan Qashqai

RRP £27,135Avg. savings £5,568 off RRP*Used from £12,606
Kia Sportage

Kia Sportage

RRP £28,065Avg. savings £2,233 off RRP*Used from £15,297
Toyota Yaris Cross

Toyota Yaris Cross

RRP £26,495Avg. savings £1,879 off RRP*Used from £15,778
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Car finance firms losing "hundreds of millions” in EV depreciation want Govt support
Car and money

Car finance firms losing "hundreds of millions” in EV depreciation want Govt support

The BVRLA says the disparity in supply and demand for electric cars is resulting in weaker-than-expected residuals, which is costing firms millions
News
11 Apr 2025
Car Deal of the Day: Elegant Mazda 3 hatch for a preeminent £178 per month
Mazda 3 front corner right

Car Deal of the Day: Elegant Mazda 3 hatch for a preeminent £178 per month

Fluid handling and even more flowing styling are the selling points of the Mazda 3 in this affordable deal
News
12 Apr 2025
New Denza Z9GT 2025 review: super estate has BMW and Mercedes in its sights
 Denza Z9GT - front tracking

New Denza Z9GT 2025 review: super estate has BMW and Mercedes in its sights

The new Denza Z9GT hybrid estate is on the way to the UK. Should BMW, Mercedes and even Porsche be worried?
Road tests
11 Apr 2025