Skip advert
Advertisement

Dacia Duster vs used Nissan Qashqai

Used crossover offers more kit and class for same cash

So the new Duster makes a strong case for itself against new car rivals. But with prices starting from £8,995, it could even be considered an alternative to a used car.

Using our 1.5 dCi Laureate’s £12,995 list price as a guide, we scoured the classifieds to find out what kind of second-hand compact SUV you could get for the same sort of money. And our hunt turned up a model that has much in common with the Dacia SUV.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The Nissan Qashqai is a similar size to the Duster, is available with the same Renault-sourced 1.5 dCi diesel and comes with a choice of two or four-wheel drive.

Our £13,000 budget turned up a 2010 post-facelift Qashqai 1.5 dCi 2WD in Acenta trim from a main dealer, with just under 20,000 miles on the clock.

Both cars can be classed as crossovers, but while the Duster has a more rugged 4x4 look, the Qashqai’s less chunky lines still appear fresh. However, unlike the car in our pictures, Acenta models don’t come with roof rails. The Duster is taller, wider and has a slightly longer wheelbase than its Nissan cousin, too, so there’s a touch more passenger space inside.

In the boot, the Qashqai trails for space, with 410 litres (compared with the Dacia’s 475 litres) and 1,513 litres with the seats folded (against the new car’s 1,636 litres).

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

However, while the Duster’s boot seems only half-finished, the Nissan’s is fully lined with carpet and plastic trim, and has a lower load lip, too. And while the seats don’t fold completely flat, carpet covers the join between the seatbacks and boot floor to leave a tidier finish than in the Dacia.

Advertisement - Article continues below

On the road, the Qashqai has the measure of the Duster in corners. Despite its tall ride height, it feels every bit as agile as a conventional hatchback, but this doesn’t come at the expense of comfort, as the Nissan does a decent job of soaking up bumps.

Although both these cars use the same 1.5-litre dCi turbodiesel engine, the Duster weighs a significant 200kg less. So it’s faster in a straight line, and is marginally more efficient, too, returning 39.8mpg on our test versus the Qashqai’s 38.1mpg.

But the biggest difference between these two is what you get for your money. While the flagship Duster has a decent level of kit, an Acenta-spec Qashqai is frankly luxurious. The car we found had everything from a six-disc CD changer, climate control and auto lights and wipers to a multifunction steering wheel, cruise control, rear parking sensors and standard stability control.

Of course, you could get an older Qashqai in a higher trim level for even less money than a Duster – high-mileage, pre-facelift models in Visia trim start at £7,000. But while an approved used Qashqai from a dealer will have a year’s warranty, the Duster will be brand new and have three years’ cover, so there’s no previous history to worry about. For some, that peace of mind is worth more than a long kit list.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

New cars that plummet in value can make brilliant used buys
Opinion - Vauxhall Corsa-e

New cars that plummet in value can make brilliant used buys

Editor Paul Barker takes a closer look at our 2024 Used Car Awards
Opinion
20 Nov 2024
A £10k electric car with a 100-mile range would surely be a sales success
Opinion - cheap EV

A £10k electric car with a 100-mile range would surely be a sales success

Mike Rutherford thinks there would be demand for an electric car with a modest 100-mile range if it only cost £10k
Opinion
17 Nov 2024
Best used cars to buy 2024
Best used cars 2024

Best used cars to buy 2024

From city cars to large SUVs, here’s our annual pick of the star performers that’ll save you thousands when you buy them used instead of new
Best cars & vans
20 Nov 2024